← All guides

Mining in winter: turning waste heat into home heating, honestly

Costs & math · 9 min read

The pitch is seductive: a miner turns electricity into heat anyway, so in winter the electricity is "free", the heat would have cost the same from a space heater, and the crypto is a bonus. There is a real idea inside that pitch, and this guide is not going to pretend otherwise. But the honest version has conditions, caps, and a season attached, and the difference between the pitch and the honest version is exactly the difference between a sensible winter setup and an expensive rationalisation. This is the heat-reuse companion to the noise and heat reality guide, that one covers living with the machine; this one covers whether its heat is genuinely worth money. Nothing here is financial advice.

The one honest sentence about mining heat

Here it is: a miner is an electric resistance heater that also mines. Electric resistance heating converts nearly 100% of the electrical energy it consumes into heat, that is a property of the physics, documented in U.S. Department of Energy material, and a miner obeys the same physics as a baseboard heater: essentially every watt it draws ends up as heat in the room. So the correct mental model is not "mining with free heating." It is "resistance heating that pays a variable rebate in crypto." Everything honest about winter mining follows from that sentence, including the caps, because a resistance heater is the benchmark the miner's heat has to beat, and it is not a high benchmark.

Size it first: watts to BTU, and what capture really means

Heating is sized in BTU per hour; miners are specced in watts. The conversion is fixed: 1 watt = 3.41214 BTU/hour. Multiply the machine's actual power draw, measured at the wall, per the electricity-cost guide, by 3.412:

Power draw at the wallGross heat outputRoughly comparable to
1,400 W (older-generation ASIC class)~4,780 BTU/hA standard 1,500 W space heater (~5,118 BTU/h)
1,500 W5,118 BTU/hOne full-size portable space heater
3,250 W (current-generation ASIC class)~11,090 BTU/hA large room / small zone heater

Gross output is not delivered heat. Between the exhaust and the room you actually want warm, some heat is lost to the wrong spaces, duct runs, and the outdoors. One mining-heat guide estimates capture at 75 to 85% for short direct ducting from the exhaust into a heated room, and 70 to 80% for ducting into a furnace's cold-air return so the existing blower distributes it. Treat those as optimistic planning figures from an interested source, not guarantees, but do apply some capture discount, because the common failure mode is sizing on the gross number and discovering the basement is toasty while the bedroom is not. At a 75% capture assumption, the 3,250 W machine delivers about 8,300 BTU/h where you want it. That is one zone of a house, not the house.

The heat credit, calculated properly

The heat credit is the heating cost the miner's delivered heat lets you avoid. It is real money, but it has three hard caps that the "free heat" pitch ignores:

Cap 1: the credit is capped at the heating you would otherwise buy. A kilowatt-hour of miner heat only displaces a kilowatt-hour of purchased heat if the room wanted that heat at that moment. Heat delivered to a room already at temperature is worth zero, worse than zero in summer, as covered below.

Cap 2: the credit is valued at your existing heating's price, per unit of heat. If the miner displaces electric baseboards, each delivered kWh of heat is worth your full electricity rate R, that is the best case. If it displaces a gas furnace, the displaced heat is worth the (usually lower) gas price per unit of heat: energy-agency material notes electric resistance heat is often more expensive than heat produced in the home by combustion appliances, so the same miner heat is worth less against gas. If it displaces a heat pump, see the comparison table below, the credit shrinks dramatically.

Cap 3: capture loss comes off the top. Only delivered heat earns the credit; the rest is just the noise-and-heat problem from the companion guide.

Worked with placeholders, for a 3,250 W machine (78 kWh/day) in deep winter, displacing electric resistance heat, at 80% capture:

delivered heat  = 78 kWh × 80%            = 62.4 kWh of heat/day
heat credit     = 62.4 × YOUR rate R
effective power cost of mining = (78 − 62.4) × R = 15.6 × R per day

That last line is the honest winter proposition: during months when the house genuinely wants all the heat the machine can deliver, the effective electricity cost of mining can fall to a fraction of the meter cost, because most of the power bill was going to be spent on heating regardless. The mining revenue then only has to beat 15.6 × R per day, not 78 × R. Notice what the formula does not say: it does not make the electricity free, it does not apply in months when the heat isn't wanted, and it collapses if the displaced heating isn't resistance electric.

Miner vs the alternatives: cost per unit of heat

Heat sourceHeat delivered per kWh of electricityWhat that means for the miner comparison
Electric resistance (baseboard, space heater)3,412 BTU, 1 kWh of electricity becomes 1 kWh of heatThe miner ties this exactly, then adds crypto revenue on top. This is the one comparison the miner wins.
ASIC miner, heat captured and wanted3,412 BTU gross; roughly 2,560 to 2,900 BTU delivered at 75 to 85% captureSlightly worse than a baseboard as a pure heater (capture loss), better once any mining revenue is counted.
Heat pumpRoughly 6,800 to 10,200 BTU, heat pumps move heat rather than creating it and are described by utility sources as two to three times more efficient than resistance heatersThe miner loses badly. Every kWh spent mining-heating is a kWh that could have delivered 2 to 3x the heat through the heat pump; the "credit" is only the resistance-equivalent value, and the household's cheapest heat was never resistance.
Gas / oil / propane furnaceNot an electricity comparison, fuel burned on siteDisplaced furnace heat is worth the fuel's price per unit of heat, typically well under the electricity rate; the credit is real but smaller than the resistance case.

The table produces the guide's central rule: winter mining heat reuse makes its strongest sense in homes heated by electric resistance, common in older Canadian housing stock with baseboards, and its weakest in homes with a heat pump, where "free heat" quietly means "heat at two to three times the necessary electricity cost, with a crypto rebate of uncertain size."

The season problem: constant heat, variable demand

A miner produces heat at a constant rate whenever it runs. A house's heat demand does the opposite, it swings with the weather, peaking in deep winter and vanishing in summer. The mismatch defines three regimes:

The practical season rule: run for heat only in months where the zone's heating demand reliably exceeds the machine's delivered output; in shoulder months, run only if the pure mining math (no heat credit) still clears your bar or the surplus can be vented without penalty; in summer, exhaust outside or shut down. An annual average that blends a great January with a terrible July is how this idea loses money while feeling clever.

A winter setup procedure

1. Confirm the counterfactual. Identify what heating the miner will actually displace, resistance, heat pump, or fuel, using the comparison table. If it's a heat pump, stop here; the honest answer is usually no.

2. Measure the machine's real draw at the wall with a meter, and convert to BTU/h with the ×3.412 factor.

3. Pick one zone whose winter heat demand exceeds the machine's delivered output (after a realistic capture discount), a basement, garage, or workshop is usually a better candidate than a bedroom, given that a current-generation ASIC at stock settings can exceed 75 dB.

4. Duct the exhaust into the zone with a shroud and short, insulated ducting; keep the run short to stay near the top of the capture range, and plan the summer exhaust route at the same time, not in June.

5. Verify on the bill, not the vibe. Compare the zone's heating energy (or the whole-home heating portion of the bill) against the same month in a prior year, weather differences in mind. The displaced heating should be visible; if it isn't, the capture assumption was wrong.

What success looks like: the target zone holds temperature with its normal heater cycling noticeably less, the machine's full output is absorbed without overheating any room, and the month's arithmetic, meter cost minus heat credit at the correct counterfactual price, matches the worked formula within a reasonable margin.

The honest bottom line

Winter heat reuse is one of the few mining ideas that survives honest accounting, in the right house. Resistance-heated home, a zone that wants the heat all winter, short ducting, and a machine that would be marginal-but-not-dead on mining alone: there, the heat credit is real, the effective power cost falls hard, and the setup can make sense. Heat-pump home, mild climate, or a machine that needs the credit to disguise economics that fail in every month: there, the "free heat" is an expensive heater with a speculative rebate. Run the counterfactual first. The season will grade the answer.

Next: Home mining's noise and heat, the reality →